Research and analysis on the transformative power of capital

 

 

 

Subprime Lending and Low-Income Communities

Center for Community Capital researchers compared subprime mortgage lending across the United States with the location of low-income and minority communities.

Maps (below) of each U.S. congressional district compare the two:

  • Left side of map — shows the location of low-income and minority residents.
  • Right side of map — shows the location of subprime loans made in that district.

Subprime Lending Maps

Congressional District % Black & Latino Average Median Income % of Subprime Loans
Alabama
0129%$32,780.2130%
0230%$31,861.8830%
0333%$29,930.9929%
048%$30,931.9837%
0519%$39,674.9726%
0611%$49,448.6124%
0762%$27,394.5044%
Alaska
007%$52,328.2422%
Arizona
0120%$34,240.2626%
0216%$46,714.7130%
0316%$55,493.5327%
0465%$30,203.5949%
0516%$57,391.4022%
0619%$53,933.3528%
0753%$31,811.3136%
0822%$45,502.8620%
Arkansas
0118%$28,876.4630%
0222%$36,939.0724%
038%$34,415.7623%
0427%$29,356.1334%
California
0119%$41,418.0020%
0215%$33,822.0727%
0314%$52,086.2024%
0410%$51,139.7118%
0535%$39,593.6435%
0616%$62,298.4415%
0738%$52,294.2330%
0826%$58,639.3111%
0945%$49,952.8326%
1021%$71,956.9223%
1124%$61,049.3124%
1218%$60,754.7713%
1328%$66,062.0021%
1421%$87,670.4212%
1519%$79,325.1414%
1641%$69,582.1522%
1746%$51,386.0122%
1847%$35,408.6539%
1932%$42,393.0041%
2068%$28,402.1644%
2147%$38,619.9533%
2227%$44,371.7234%
2346%$46,599.2921%
2424%$63,468.7117%
2535%$55,007.2038%
2629%$64,570.4422%
2742%$51,570.1330%
2859%$43,191.6731%
2932%$48,179.4519%
3011%$79,699.4113%
3173%$27,585.1032%
3266%$41,481.5131%
3365%$34,228.9631%
3481%$30,383.2234%
3581%$34,650.7440%
3633%$53,866.4916%
3769%$35,417.1740%
3874%$44,682.7935%
3967%$46,295.6433%
4033%$57,898.1124%
4129%$39,878.0637%
4227%$73,557.2520%
4371%$35,619.8045%
4441%$56,433.3531%
4543%$40,802.0534%
4621%$66,500.1316%
4766%$42,908.1639%
4817%$75,309.2715%
4935%$47,761.0031%
5021%$67,761.4016%
5163%$41,561.8231%
5217%$57,157.9619%
5337%$40,157.1020%
Colorado
0140%$43,548.0538%
0216%$58,507.8220%
0322%$36,292.0025%
0418%$43,547.9724%
0516%$46,935.5624%
068%$75,965.9121%
0726%$48,781.7331%
Connecticut
0124%$49,331.4725%
027%$56,111.4021%
0319%$50,936.2127%
0424%$80,124.0022%
0516%$55,964.9525%
Delaware
0024%$48,655.5923%
District of Columbia
9868%$43,110.3123%
Florida
0117%$36,627.5425%
0226%$34,848.2323%
0352%$29,999.1647%
0419%$44,338.1426%
0510%$35,161.2331%
0617%$38,614.8230%
0717%$44,174.0928%
0826%$44,869.2034%
0913%$45,855.2130%
108%$38,657.8628%
1147%$34,324.0643%
1224%$37,646.3339%
1313%$43,599.6225%
1414%$46,327.1432%
1518%$41,522.9832%
1615%$42,543.5332%
1776%$30,645.3155%
1868%$40,933.5736%
1919%$49,537.4633%
2032%$47,416.7133%
2177%$45,677.2143%
2215%$56,811.9625%
2361%$32,469.1845%
2417%$45,398.6130%
2573%$44,757.2645%
Georgia
0126%$36,098.9225%
0248%$29,085.9634%
0342%$29,821.0037%
0462%$52,205.5838%
0561%$36,853.1734%
0612%$79,649.1320%
0713%$61,806.6826%
0818%$52,545.9529%
0917%$40,135.8326%
1013%$41,462.8829%
1134%$37,718.1434%
1246%$29,973.6962%
1350%$44,367.7143%
Hawaii
017%$55,371.5221%
0210%$51,479.5024%
Idaho
017%$37,947.5724%
029%$37,928.8824%
Illinois
0172%$33,956.4352%
0272%$41,389.6658%
0328%$47,672.9635%
0478%$36,989.4438%
0526%$51,263.5426%
0615%$66,343.8026%
0767%$37,363.5535%
0813%$67,731.1126%
0923%$54,213.6723%
1018%$83,388.5521%
1115%$46,765.8830%
1218%$27,795.1829%
1310%$73,982.1924%
1423%$54,596.9028%
158%$40,369.6622%
1612%$48,349.1728%
1710%$34,824.8930%
188%$42,365.5521%
195%$38,298.7521%
Indiana
015%$38,298.7521%
0213%$40,167.0131%
036%$42,853.3525%
044%$45,938.0413%
054%$52,578.3923%
065%$39,044.7531%
0734%$36,309.3841%
084%$36,637.0026%
094%$39,293.0025%
Iowa
016%$38,704.2024%
025%$40,720.7920%
036%$42,853.3525%
043%$38,703.2325%
054%$37,141.3431%
Kansas
0113%$35,002.0328%
028%$38,223.9526%
0316%$53,775.3223%
0413%$42,254.5426%
Kentucky
018%$30,250.8531%
027%$35,460.2528%
0320%$40,794.2325%
0432%$40,607.3724%
0517%$21,554.0636%
0610%$38,982.0024%
Louisiana
0118%$42,922.4822%
0264%$23,226.6633%
0326%$34,483.0033%
0435%$30,661.8736%
0535%$27,281.7338%
0635%$37,298.3032%
0726%$32,425.9729%
Maine
011%$42,496.8421%
021%$32,947.0031%
Maryland
0113%$53,664.5921%
0228%$45,949.4936%
0320%$54,777.7725%
0464%$60,894.2740%
0533%$64,324.2933%
065%$49,814.4722%
0760%$39,503.8738%
0830%$77,958.2723%
Massachusetts
018%$43,269.8723%
0215%$44,263.8027%
039%$51,127.1222%
045%$58,035.3318%
0513%$59,462.9722%
066%$59,038.3617%
078%$62,381.8119%
0838%$40,736.2223%
0913%$57,924.4923%
103%$54,443.5617%
Michigan
012%$34,320.3528%
0210%$41,473.7626%
0314%$47,139.3828%
043%$39,335.2226%
0522%$39,966.8434%
0612%$41,086.3228%
078%$45,825.5929%
088%$57,372.1725%
0911%$73,357.0621%
104%$53,847.3423%
116%$61,641.5924%
1213%$48,406.3335%
1368%$32,396.3560%
1463%$36,872.9459%
1514%$51,304.5430%
Minnesota
014%$42,549.2223%
024%$64,219.2423%
036%$66,978.294%
0412%$47,815.3328%
0519%$42,531.2729%
062%$59,831.0324%
073%$36,591.0025%
081%$37,221.3126%
Mississippi
0128%$32,922.9523%
0264%$27,676.6123%
032%$32,949.884%
0424%$32,195.0028%
Missouri
0152%$33,527.8248%
024%$51,744.6619%
0311%$41,534.1528%
044%$34,840.3629%
0529%$37,472.0937%
065%$42,097.4428%
074%$34,616.2527%
085%$27,894.4166%
095%$37,571.3724%
Montana
002%$33,199.2621%
Nebraska
016%$41,534.3821%
0216%$48,424.2223%
036%$33,949.0134%
Nevada
0140%$43,451.7838%
0218%$46,912.8624%
0321%$53,949.0430%
New Hampshire
012%$40,387.1922%
022%$50,481.3624%
New Jersey
0125%$48,838.8428%
0224%$44,903.7425%
0312%$58,061.7022%
0414%$57,542.6121%
056%$77,072.0517%
0628%$57,088.9725%
0711%$78,388.0417%
0838%$45,040.3230%
0926%$54,503.3325%
1071%$39,807.8846%
119%$82,923.9415%
1217%$73,284.8917%
1358%$38,336.9132%
New Mexico
0145%$41,626.7724%
0251%$29,019.5929%
0340%$37,762.9023%
New York
0111%$64,520.8126%
0224%$74,050.6334%
039%$74,990.8316%
0431%$69,986.9737%
0527%$59,909.4815%
0670%$46,592.0747%
0757%$38,661.3833%
0817%$45,218.478%
092%$49,091.3521%
1079%$35,286.3144%
1171%$37,285.0532%
1258%$33,010.7630%
1317%$49,314.9025%
1417%$56,279.976%
1578%$28,374.1610%
1693%$15,871.1143%
1751%$48,291.8232%
1825%$78,835.0518%
1912%$67,228.2123%
204%$44,601.9323%
2110%$41,320.9829%
2216%$38,454.4028%
234%$35,664.0725%
245%$35,915.8723%
259%$44,096.9620%
265%$46,844.5521%
279%$36,605.8224%
2834%$31,819.3030%
294%$42,556.6021%
North Carolina
0152%$28,437.0030%
0237%$35,240.0124%
0323%$37,279.8618%
0426%$52,637.7617%
0511%$40,956.9423%
0614%$44,373.1724%
0763%$33,411.5721%
0834%$37,741.9929%
0915%$57,033.7723%
1013%$36,924.2926%
117%$34,229.7621%
1253%$32,834.0734%
1332%$41,649.7425%
North Dakota
002%$34,985.0019%
Ohio
0128%$37,964.1432%
025%$48,462.7722%
0318%$42,140.7228%
046%$39,111.0230%
055%$42,128.4328%
063%$32,317.9227%
078%$44,114.7529%
085%$35,097.7128%
0917%$40,337.7028%
1010%$41,872.5127%
1157%$34,182.0344%
1223%$49,493.2225%
1315%$45,481.2628%
144%$55,650.1622%
1510%$45,087.0626%
166%$41,710.7928%
1713%$35,555.9634%
183%$34,450.8833%
Oklahoma
0115%$42,515.3828%
026%$29,183.4938%
039%$32,515.2232%
0411%$35,700.1228%
0522%$35,243.7028%
Oregon
0110%$50,066.2922%
029%$35,937.5323%
0313%$43,427.1225%
045%$37,422.9724%
0511%$45,391.0324%
Pennsylvania
0158%$28,698.1236%
0265%$34,180.2832%
035%$35,880.9922%
045%$35,880.9922%
054%$45,172.0220%
062%$33,965.5523%
0710%$58,865.2617%
087%$60,004.0817%
096%$60,034.0614%
103%$34,010.3823%
115%$34,517.2530%
124%$30,462.0627%
138%$54,680.9718%
1423%$30,692.9932%
1510%$45,527.7021%
1613%$46,460.7817%
1710%$40,121.1922%
183%$46,186.4719%
196%$44,541.7820%
Rhode Island
0111%$42,203.0325%
0214%$44,586.9630%
South Carolina
0124%$40,353.1123%
0230%$44,955.1925%
0322%$36,457.6328%
0423%$37,583.3627%
0534%$35,099.4630%
0658%$28,307.1638%
South Dakota
002%$34,213.1121%
Tennessee
014%$30,898.0027%
027%$36,033.0026%
0312%$35,150.0030%
046%$32,063.0017%
0529%$40,869.0025%
069%$38,894.0027%
0717%$42,416.0023%
0823%$33,839.0035%
0962%$33,462.6844%
Texas
0128%$33,205.5329%
0231%$45,189.5635%
0326%$66,542.0224%
0418%$37,874.4927%
0525%$41,694.6635%
0628%$46,403.1132%
0725%$68,360.7124%
0818%$42,201.9728%
0969%$37,116.9249%
1029%$55,875.9629%
1134%$33,584.2132%
1229%$43,373.6030%
1323%$33,676.8627%
1434%$42,157.2227%
1576%$28,848.0443%
1681%$31,821.1334%
1726%$35,305.7529%
1875%$30,949.7445%
1934%$32,659.2129%
2074%$31,297.0038%
2123%$58,909.9817%
2230%$58,659.0031%
2357%$38,343.0024%
2428%$60,668.5828%
2575%$26,611.4337%
2630%$45,592.3726%
2773%$31,505.0036%
2874%$31,435.0036%
2976%$32,196.0053%
3075%$35,054.3447%
3139%$43,117.6321%
3244%$59,380.2225%
Utah
0112%$47,062.0225%
026%$50,022.3123%
0310%$49,212.2030%
Vermont
011%$40,700.8518%
Virginia
0121%$51,618.7729%
0225%$46,069.1235%
0358%$33,254.1724%
0435%$42,880.2627%
0525%$35,597.9635%
0613%$37,602.2132%
0717%$55,124.4224%
08
095%$29,992.0028%
1014%$76,772.2521%
1119%$76,772.2522%
Washington
016%$61,392.6318%
027%$47,030.6224%
036%$44,506.2226%
0427%$38,591.6125%
056%$37,322.8623%
0611%$39,468.8729%
0714%$48,799.8315%
086%$67,461.5121%
0913%$48,164.5929%
West Virginia
012%$30,223.6323%
024%$33,079.4125%
034%$25,482.6728%
Wisconsin
0110%$49,854.9324%
027%$50,079.9816%
031%$39,800.3223%
0444%$32,081.9143%
053%$49,404.2616%
063%$43,886.1222%
071%$38,461.8723%
083%$42,937.4419%
Wyoming
007%$38,418.5026%

Background on Research

The Center for Community Capital created these maps in 2007 at the request of the Center for Responsible Lending, a nonprofit advocacy group, which distributed them to members of the U.S. Congress to expose discriminatory practices in subprime mortgage lending.

Subprime loans are those loans issued to persons with low or blemished credit scores. Greater attention has been paid to subprime mortgage lending practices since it has been demonstrated that these loans are disproportionately issued to low income and minority populations.

Notes and Data Sources

Unit of observation: Census tracts

N/A: Census tracts for which no data is displayed for one of two reasons: 1. Census tract boundaries do no necessarily coincide with congressional district boundaries. Therefore, each census tract was "assigned" entirely to the congressional district within which a majority of its area lies. 2. No data was available for the census tract.
Left-hand map: Below 80% District Median Income — median income was obtained for each census tract with a majority area within the congressional district, and then averaged. The average was then multiplied by 80% to arrive at the value that equals 80% of the Area Medium Income. This number will differ for each congressional district.

Above District % Black and Latino — for each census tract within the congressional district, total, black and Latino populations were totaled. The total black and Latino population for the district was divided by the total district population to arrive at the percentage of blacks and Latinos in the district, and thus differs for each congressional district.

Right-hand map: Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA) data was used to determine the total number of mortgages issued, and the total number of subprime mortgages issued by census tract for 2005 and 2006. This map displays subprime mortgage issuance as a percentage of total mortgage issuance by census tract.

© 2010 Center for Community Capital • College of Arts and SciencesThe University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
1700 Martin Luther King Blvd., Suite 129 • CB#3452, Chapel Hill NC 27599-3452 • 919.843.2140 • 877.783.2359 • communitycapital@unc.edu